Comments on: The Secret Lives of Internet Cafes

By: M.Arslan

M.Arslan — Wed, 17 Mar 2010 13:41:53 +0000

Hello,
I want to say that all the brothers and ladies that pakistan is our country.yeh hamara country hai aur hum ny ese theak krna hai

By: unknown

unknown — Fri, 05 Mar 2010 15:36:23 +0000

I read the comments of some men here that say , that unless the girl doesnt want nothing happens.. Its very unfortunate that the men in our society think they can do what ever and get away with it. Who gave men the permission to do what ever they want. Does Islam give it? Does the government give it?.. its just so lame for men to think that its ok for them to do what ever and it doesnt matter ..

For those men who think it doesnt matter .. well heres an eye opener .. U WILL DIE ONE DAY AND WHO WILL SAVE U THEN. ITS NOT PERMITTED IN OUR RELIGION SO THERE IS NO REASON TO JUDGE GIRLS AND GIVE UR LAME COMMENTS.

and for the guys and girls who did make this mistake, no one has the right to judge them , every person makes mistake and there is no reason to exploit ppl like that..

May Allah forgive Them and Give those mindless idiots who exploit ppl a little humanity

By: sami afridi

sami afridi — Mon, 22 Feb 2010 08:57:08 +0000

why the people diong lick this things they should be know the ALLAH is watching every thing

By: Arch.Asad

Arch.Asad — Sat, 20 Feb 2010 04:41:57 +0000

Asalam alakoum
My name is Asad Ullah Khan i am the student of Architecture.
My suggestion is that every parent should be very frank with there child otherwise this will happen again in future and Islamic Law should be impose in Pakistan rather then English Law of 1905.
A gang was involve in this activity because i was done at large scale.
One day i sit in the park a man come to me and told me that “i have girls of school,college and uni do you want any”. That kind of group is involved not boy or girl is targeted to say that they are wrong may be they belong to good family be rouin there life by that broker(DALAL).ake.

By: Khan

Khan — Sat, 30 Jan 2010 19:03:30 +0000

Mr Bilour a prominent Politician of Peshawar earned billions from porn films that were shown in his cinemas in Peshawar. They also sell condoms so that people may relieve themselves during the shows. What do you expect from the government ?
PORN!

By: aqeel

aqeel — Fri, 15 Jan 2010 12:18:49 +0000

i am very upset for all of this . every have a past and there giltyes but you can not appologise like this.pnishment not for that peoples in the cafe.we punished that black melers.and that cafe owners.they made of those peoples life getting die…

By: Flaba

Flaba — Fri, 15 Jan 2010 03:53:50 +0000

Listen up and listen up good because I read all of your damn comments on this page(plus the article)…and needless to say over 90% are biased, wrong, blind (religion, culture, not being educated,ect), and a great example of how ignorant both America AND everyone else (the world) can be. All told it isn’t about race the majority of America is stupid and the majority of every other country is stupid. No exceptions, no racism, just fact.

Now lets get down to business. Simply put it isn’t the persons who video taped its fault. It is all of your own damned fault. For creating a taboo that is irrational and contradictory to the NATURAL human experience, of course I am speaking of the natural curiosity of sexuality. If you as a people did not become so damn conservative and think this is “sin” or wrong or not supposed to happen due to your culture let me tell you now you will NEVER accomplish this task and you WILL be defeated in due time. If you as a people accepted sexuality as a necessary part of humanity you wouldn’t be so outraged and ashamed, there would be no scandal, and life would continue on.

So all this talk of getting rid of cameras and setting up internet site blockers won’t get rid of the problem. LOL you know WHAT? It won’t even slow it down, not even a bit. You know what it WILL do? Haha you’ll love it. It WILL only encourage people to look for those “dirty sites”. Like an adult who never got to eat his favorite candy as a child because his mom said no…now he eats it everyday.

Oh and Ahamed? You say it is your culture for boys and girls not to chat and stay shy? Yet the internet lets them chat. So the internet is bad now? No sir indeed you were the problem all along. The internet just gave them the opportunity to talk…one you denied them for so long. Culture and religion should not interfere with human rights and if they do they are void. Guess what? Yours is void for violating freedom of speech, pursuit of happiness, …so many others..

Iqbal you say we shouldn’t comment anymore? Keeping the thread alive is also seen as bad custom on internet forums. Why? No reason really other than to move on to the next thing. But the situation doesn’t move on…the problem does not move on. Should you forget this happened it will only happen again. You are held responsible now to remember and do whatever is in your power to stop it from happening again.

Three of the girls in the scandal committed suicide. One was killed by her father. Two were divorced. The suicidal ones are your fault. The flawed rules and ideals you make them accept at birth skewed their sense of what is right or wrong from their very birth. The father was a conservative idiot who can only think of honor and whats right for “the greater good”, the ones that got divorced prove their relationships weren’t real to begin with since their marriage couldn’t last the most minuscule and laughable of obstacles. Yes laughable, they make videos of people catching their friends (male or female) watching “dirty sites” in America, Britain, and all the sane countries. They call it a joke. You call it sin. Sin you must pay for with your life, respect, honor,…ect. Ridiculous really.

Grow up and become civilized. Then you won’t have these problems. You’ll have OUR problems. Then maybe just maybe…you can advance on to the best plate. My problems, as an intellectual who views and comments on all this nonsense yet can have no hand in stopping it. Perhaps I should make my own nation.

No crazy people allowed.

By: shahana

shahana — Mon, 21 Dec 2009 20:48:24 +0000

i am feeling guilty .death is not the solution of all problm.

By: Muhammad Iftikhar Mirza

Muhammad Iftikhar Mirza — Sat, 24 Oct 2009 09:14:45 +0000

I 200% agree with Mr. Liaquat Ali and Ms. Sana. Beauifully shown us what we are. Atleast i own it.

By: Muhammad Iftikhar Mirza

Muhammad Iftikhar Mirza — Sat, 24 Oct 2009 08:54:22 +0000

I have seen most of the material avaiable. I do not blame the couples involved in such act(s) coz all of us are not so MOMIN. It is God who know how bad and how ugly we are. No one is perfect so Allah never encouraged to make such acts public. The men / gang involved in such game much be punished. His criminal adventure took many lives. Such things cannot be prevented, these have been done in the past which is continued today and will in future. These will occure and can we say that these are not being done today. No dear these acts are being done every where around us, every day and every minute and moraly and ethically we should not advertise these things. Every one has its private life and no body has any right whatsoever to ruin it. Try to love humabeing and human values and hate sins.

Bye and take care.

By: Jamil Ahmed Farooqi

Jamil Ahmed Farooqi — Fri, 09 Oct 2009 11:29:35 +0000

Dear Nations!
IF YOU ARE DOING SUCH THINGS THEN READY FOR THE WORST OUTCOME OF THESE THINGS…SPECIALLY GIRLS ARE LOOSING THEIR ALL. SO KINDLY MAKE OUR COUNTRY FREE FROM SUCH BAD HABIT, OTHERWISE GOD WILL NEVER FORGIVE US…

By: anuj

anuj — Sun, 04 Oct 2009 05:24:36 +0000

the videos should have never been recorded

What people do in their private lives is their business not for anyone else to judge.
Let god do the judging… and in any case all the people who have commented here arent angels themselves…. every1 has done something in their lives which if recorded and put up on youtube wud embarass the hell out of u…so please refrain from judging others

One advice for all the super moralistic people here

RELAX…. u don’t have to play god and judge others… just be human and relax.

By: Wakas Mir

Wakas Mir — Wed, 30 Sep 2009 21:57:58 +0000

This is so sad. I guess the person who was responsible including everyone in the “team” should have been made a national issue and put on the electric chair and then hung a 100 times. This is so sick, what the girls n guys did is a result of the “amazing wonderful western culture” that we Pakistanis welcome via the silly old cables and dishes on each street in Pakistan.

First thing that has to be done is to tell children from the start what they should NEVER do and that is to trust anyone who claims to “love them” and makes them do something like this… kids to bache hote hi hein lekin bade to bade banein!

By: afghan bacha

afghan bacha — Mon, 28 Sep 2009 14:09:40 +0000

it is not smthing to discuss and make it as large, dosnt matter, they were enjoying their life with their lover, so pak is an islamic country that is Y the make this issue so big, if the allow the cuoples so the will not do this in net club, it means that if the strict more and more but the pple do their enjoyment if it is in net club or along the street..lolzzzz im complety fine with this issue, they did well as the did.

THANKS

By: ahsan

ahsan — Sat, 26 Sep 2009 19:44:48 +0000

i think its a really very cheap act from the internet cafe.bcz acording to islam if god do not open any one secreate than we human being should be carefull abt this.
we have no right to c any 1 private life
may god blesss the families has been destroyed by thease kind of stupid things and give them peace and calm

By: IMRAN FROM RAWALPINDI

IMRAN FROM RAWALPINDI — Wed, 23 Sep 2009 03:56:28 +0000

I HAVE ONLY TWO WORDS FOR THESE VIDEOS MAKING GANGS…… FUCK YOU ALLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL …………… EVERY1 MAKE MISTAKES BUT GOD FORGIVE FORGIVE AGAIN ND AGAIN BT WE PEOPLE R SO SILLY REALLY ……………………………. SO PLZ PLZ GIRLS AND GUYS BECARELYYYYYYYYYYYY SPECIALLY GIRLS PLZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ

By: Khan

Khan — Sun, 23 Aug 2009 11:34:32 +0000

Is there any technology which has not been misused ? Technology has always been misused but it is the government, who control the misuse. A gun can be good and evil at the same time. The same is with the net cafe. It is good and evil at the same time. If the owners use it to earn and spread computer education, it is a good thing but if they are using as it was, then it is of course evil.
I did not see the morale of the Jang story. That what happened to the owner of the net cafe. Instead of these guys and girls, who commit suicide or run away from homes, it was more logical to punish the net cafe owner. So that nobody dare to do the same in future.

By: hell

hell — Fri, 31 Jul 2009 19:00:19 +0000

my questions are the same ..
those girls who commits suicides..what were they doing in cafe on the very first place?

the problem with our nation is that its way much emotional
If a truck driver killed a baby the people kill that driver on the spot without even thinking for a second that whose responsible for such thing..the mothers who let there small children run away and play on the roads. I have seen many times that they are walking on roads with there children like its some sort of fuckin amusement part :/ And once someone get killed then its the driver fault always…

SO to all the people who are saying that those blackmailers were the bad ones or the cafe owner is responsible..

please review your opinion regarding it…

IF YOU GIVE SOMEONE CHANCE TO MAKE A VIDEO OF YOU >>>WHY DONT THEY USE THAT CHANCE ….

IF YOU ARE DOING SUCH THINGS THEN READY FOR THE WORST OUTCOME OF THESE THINGS…

By: LION KING

LION KING — Sat, 30 May 2009 05:23:54 +0000

DEFINITELY WE HAVE TO TAKE ACTION. THE FIRST THING IS TO CONTROL OUR CHILDREN. BASICALLY OUR MEDIA IS SUPPORTING WEST. N OUR YOUNGER GENERATION IS FALLOWING IN THE WRONG DIRECTION. WE HAVE TO CHECK THEM AND TAKE NECESSARY PRECAUTIONS FOR THEM. I KNOW ITS A HARD TIME FOR ALL THOSE WHO LOST THEIR BELOVED ONCE. BUT STILL THEIR IS LAGGING IN OUR SELF SO FIRST WE HAVE TO CONTROL OUR CHILDREN. I M SO SO SO SORRY FOR ALL THOSE WHO LOST THEIR FAMILY MEMBERS. MAY GOD HELP US TO HELP OTHERS. GOD BLESS N SAVE OUR PAKISTAN. N DESTROY ALL THOSE WHO TAKE PART N BLACK MAIL THE YOUNG BLOOD.

By: faceless

faceless — Fri, 29 May 2009 16:16:18 +0000

You cant just lash a bunch of people for these things. The blackmailers are the ones to be punished, what two people do is their own business. I know its disgusting engaging in sexual acts in public but some of these girls apparentley ended up commiting suicide, they didnt deserve to die over this.